If We Could Eat Nightmare Fuel

[johnsnake71]

... what would happen?

[Boar Head]

Once you eat 15 nightmare fuel it comes together in your stomach and forms a terrorbeak that comes out of your mouth.

[TeoSS69]

We'd have a bad case of diarrhea.

[ARamblingSpider]

We'd have a bad case of diarrhea.

sounds snazzy

[Krac]

We'd s**t bricks?

[Tesability]

We'd s**t bricks?

That's probably putting it mildly. Either way, Nightmare Fuel would probably wreck the digestive system to a severe degree.

[Craig_Perry]

so that's why william turned into maxwell... damnit this is my theory now XD (if they are the same person that is)

[hectorluis13]

if you eat nightmare fuel your own belly will might turn dark and have it's own mind and you will only hear what it says when your sanity is low.
Also, you will have nightmares the next time you sleep

[Luggs]

if you eat nightmare fuel your own belly will might turn dark and have it's own mind and you will only hear what it says when your sanity is low.

Also, you will have nightmares the next time you sleep

"Feed me, Seymour."

I think it'd corrupt your very soul. Twist your mind til your nothing but a beast.

[xSadoro]

I think if you carry any nightmare fuel , when you go to sleep , the possibilities should be:

 

*You have a nightmare and loose hp

 

*2 terrorbeaks spawn next to you when you wake up

 

*You have 1% chance to die

[Boar Head]

I think if you carry any nightmare fuel , when you go to sleep , the possibilities should be:

 

*You have a nightmare and loose hp

 

*2 terrorbeaks spawn next to you when you wake up

 

*You have 1% chance to die

Those are pretty cheap...and really easy to avoid so kind of redundant at the same time....

[Hugo M.]

We'd puke, a lot.

[Shoggoth]

I think if we ate nightmare fuel we'd begin doing things like holding long conversations with ourselves and making racecars out of our poop.

[can't starve]

Nightmare poop.

[ARamblingSpider]

Those are pretty cheap...and really easy to avoid so kind of redundant at the same time....

What if you lost sanity depending on the amount of nightmare fuel you had with you? like a 2% drop for each piece.

[The Letter W]

I don't know, but I don't recommend mixing it with the uncooked Green Cap. You might get some undesirable results. 

[Battal]

You'd gain a ridiculous obsession in meat bycicles, and would run around killing things with an axe made from a saw blade.

[Guest]

You would start puking out Chuck Norris while random wooden bracelets rained from the sky singing Hannah Montana.

[The Letter W]

You'd gain a ridiculous obsession in meat bycicles, and would run around killing things with an axe made from a saw blade.

I'm assuming the saw blades are your new bicycle wheels. 

[Tonguetyd]

Eating Nightmare Fuel would make you poop Nightmare Manure that you could use to make Nightmare Farms which would grow Nightmare Vegetables that you can make into Nightmare Foods that you can eat to make more Nightmare Farms.

[jangofet]

Eating Nightmare Fuel would make you poop Nightmare Manure that you could use to make Nightmare Farms which would grow Nightmare Vegetables that you can make into Nightmare Foods that you can eat to make more Nightmare Farms.

wha....

 

Anyways, If you eat nightmare fuel, a terrorbeak army comes to kill you for eating their kind.

[aluxo]

I have a suggestion: If you ate... let´s say... 15-20 Nightmare Fuel. You would transform into a night hound and terrorize everything!

[Ellthan]

It heal health and decrease sanity, opposite of taffy, but would make adventure really easy.

[Warrick]

We'd have a bad case of diarrhea.

yet our characters seem always constipated

[the truthseeker]

You would start puking out Chuck Norris while random wooden bracelets rained from the sky singing Hannah Montana.

 

Welp, there goes my literal reply