Terra Firma Tamper Landscaping addition poll

[wons]

i voted for yes
why?
1. it would make everything in dst renewable
2. for me now this machine isn't that much worth it, sure turfs are fun but struggle with all those puzzles and just for a turf machine only?
3. why not

[Queron81]

No, because it's just tamping ressources to a turf. It just wouldn't make sense to get Berrie Bushes or other plants out of it this way.

For plants I would prefer a solution like the Sprouting Stone Fruit, like getting a Sprouting Berrie from time to time.

[chirsg]

7 hours ago, Queron81 said:

It just wouldn't make sense to get Berrie Bushes or other plants out of it this way.

terra firma tamper opens the landscaping tab. Planting saplings and bushes is by every single possible definition, landscaping

If this doesn't make sense, then the clouds in the sky are marshmallows. 

[-Nick-]

I dont like the idea to be able to create resources, it feels off. What i want is to be able to craft lumpy tree cones, lunar saplings, and the tropical variant of the berry bush.

[chirsg]

2 minutes ago, Nickolai said:

lunar saplings

It's already very possible in the base game. 

 

 

3 minutes ago, Nickolai said:

tropical variant of the berry bush.

If we get expanded options in landscaping, I proposed that adding a spiky berry bush would be possible

[-Nick-]

Just now, chirsg said:

If we get expanded options in landscaping, I proposed that adding a spiky berry bush would be possible

Yeah good idea, spiky bushes are underrated. They are really good with a wormwood around.

[AlternateMew]

I was on board until someone pointed out what Terra Firma Tamper translates to.

Still though, I just want a nice way to get plants for decorating. I fear using my few pig village berry bushes because any accident that destroys them will mean they're gone for good, but they're so cool looking.

And to be absolutely clear: Terra Firma Tamper is good and I'm glad we can finally craft turfs. That is a huge plus on its own.

[Queron81]

13 hours ago, chirsg said:

terra firma tamper opens the landscaping tab. Planting saplings and bushes is by every single possible definition, landscaping

If this doesn't make sense, then the clouds in the sky are marshmallows. 

It doesn't matter, how the tab is named. The Terra Firma Tamper ist TAMPING materials, so that there is only a mix of the ingredients left. It isn't really creating something, it is destroying things, like you are putting fruits in a bender. At the end you have a mixed mass, not a new fruit.

You can't create a plant, you can only plant a seed of a plant and hope it's growing. The you can do landscaping with these plants, like replanting them.

[Mime]

While i believe the terra firma should be used for other types of recipes, i think a better way of creating large scale farms would be nice.