Wendy's suggestion post collection since December 12th （updated）

[Yaorin yon]

6 minutes ago, Debruh said:

They fixed what people complained about.

Accessibility issues? Fixed

Her 25% phase? Fixed

Those were the problems complained about most

The comment section you are in is a compilation post of complaints and suggestions. If you had taken a brief look, you would know that what you are talking about is actually just a very small part of what has been addressed.

[Debruh]

3 minutes ago, Yaorin yon said:

The comment section you are in is a compilation post of complaints and suggestions. If you had taken a brief look, you would know that what you are talking about is actually just a very small part of what has been addressed.

A lot of which talk about accessibility, and/or the 25% health thing.

The rest are complete overhauls that are obviously not going to be done, such as making her untargetable and changing thr way she attacks.

Some ask for her to be completely removed, while others say that she is good, and her only problem is the accessibility.

Others are just asking for old busted boss soloing gestalt Abby to be back, which is obviously not gonna happen

[Yaorin yon]

16 minutes ago, Debruh said:

A lot of which talk about accessibility, and/or the 25% health thing.

The rest are complete overhauls that are obviously not going to be done, such as making her untargetable and changing thr way she attacks.

Some ask for her to be completely removed, while others say that she is good, and her only problem is the accessibility.

Others are just asking for old busted boss soloing gestalt Abby to be back, which is obviously not gonna happen

First and foremost, the most important question: Why are significant reforms not allowed...?
I used to admire Klei for their willingness to make bold changes, such as replacing the unpopular glass cannon Wendy with Wanda, who was a much more satisfying character. Many demands for major reforms were repeatedly emphasized when this test server began. Yet, the current development team has been ignoring and delaying responses to these demands, dragging them out until today, and then having others tell you, “It’s too late for major reforms now.”
Should this be tolerated? It should be condemned.

Secondly, there are many issues that have been emphasized since their inception but still haven’t been adequately addressed:

1. The independent cooldown of Team Spirit, the probability of being haunted, and the removal of cooldowns.
2. Mourning Glory Wreath should retain its original potion duration when re-equipped.
3. Abigail and Mourning Glory Wreath need to run two or even more types of potions simultaneously.
4. Pipspooks’ quests are boring and need more ways to obtain Mourning Glory or improve the compatibility of Pipspooks’ quests with daily life.
5. Lunar Abigail is currently very weak (and still being nerfed).
6. The trigger mechanism for Shadow Abigail is poorly designed.
7. The entire Blessed Sisturn branch is of low quality and needs improvement, especially the handling of Sisturn3, which is particularly bad.
8. The function of tombstones is practically useless.
9. The Mourning Glory Altar is just a reskinned meat statue.
10. Vengeful Spirits are meaningless.
    And there are many more significant issues.
    Instead of addressing these, the development team is once again focusing on minor details, like reviving butterflies and moths, which is not praiseworthy. Wortox should know that in the future, it would be better to directly give you a bug net rather than reviving butterflies and moths.
    I won’t be impressed by Klei just because they’ve added 100 new recipes for the Pinetree Pioneer Hat for Walter.

[GetNerfedOn]

Nice!

To improve accessibility you can keep all of the links per section in a spoiler below the section head, like this for example:

Lunar/Shadow abi

Spoiler

Survey on the strength adjustment of Gestalt：Do you think Gestalt should be adjusted to match the strength of Shadow Abi? - [Don't Starve Together] Beta Branch - Klei Entertainment Forums

The way Gestalt and Shadow Abigail are designed and gated makes no sense - [Don't Starve Together] Beta Branch - Klei Entertainment Forums

The Balance Between Shadow and Moon – Wendy's Skill Tree - [Don't Starve Together] Beta Branch - Klei Entertainment Forums

A thought about balance of Gestalt and Shadow

[Poll] Which do you prefer: Lunar Affinity or Shadow Affinity? - [Don't Starve Together] Beta Branch - Klei Entertainment Forums

Just click the eye symbol on the formatting bar to make a spoiler.

[Bumber64]

23 hours ago, Koomin said:

From the update:

Wendy
- Gestalt Abigail can be mutated during a waxing and full moon  now, and returned to a regular ghost during a waning and new moon. (Buff, ease of transformation is a suggestion in this thread links)
- Reduced the amount of Planar Defence added with the Shadow Sisterhood III buff.  (Nerf, not sure if in this thread)
- Cursed Vexation does not alter Abigail’s vex multiplier. It now just adds some flat Planar Damage. (Mostly nerf, sometimes buff, suggested in this thread links)
- Moon Moths can be crafted with the Mourning Glory I skill. (Buff, suggested all the time)
- Wendy can add Mourning Glory to the Picnic Casket. (Buff, suggested in this thread links)
- When Unyielding Draught and Distilled Vengeance are used on a survivor, they are no longer one use only. Now there is a 10 second cooldown before it will work again, but this will last until the end of the elixir's duration.  (Buff, not sure if in this thread)

3x buffs, 1x nerf, 1x maybe nerf 

Overall most of the changes were buffs, and most of them from this thread.  I'm not sure why whenever any nerfs happen everyone ignores all the buffs and instead is upset.  These suggestions are clearly being taken into account, and everything is not just being weakened.

You forgot scare becoming uninterruptible. People wanted it to not go on cooldown if it failed, but we got something that just doesn't fail now.

The negativity bias is on full display.

[Catapult 2.0]

@Jason

This post has compiled and categorized a large number of high-quality suggestions for you, which can save you a significant amount of work. If you truly want to create a skill tree that satisfies the majority of players, I would recommend reading them carefully.