[Poll] Which do you prefer: Lunar Affinity or Shadow Affinity?

[Yifei_]

A small survey on the affinity skills of Wendy, Wortox, and Walter's skill trees.

[salty_cookie]

As someone who is supported by todays sponsor voxola I only use lunar affinity. Use code “please make it stop” for 50% off your next brightshade order.

[ColdHeaven]

Here it is. Alright klei it's time to buff gestalt abigail

[Mysterious box]

There's really no reason to use the lunar side currently for Walter so I'm surprised it even got a vote.

Edit: I guess unless people just like the look of the brilliance effect?

[Koomin]

1 hour ago, ColdHeaven said:

Here it is. Alright klei it's time to buff gestalt abigail

Or weaken shadow Abigail

[Steorra]

4 minutes ago, Koomin said:

Or weaken shadow Abigail

never mind, I still won't use both of them 

so I guess they still need some improvement lol

[Koomin]

3 minutes ago, Fitzee said:

You're quite persistent about this, aren't you?

Here's a copypaste of a statement I made explaining why this outcome is unlikely:

From the looks of it in my perspective, if Klei felt like it was warranted for Shadow Abigail to be nerfed in the damage department, they would've done so by now, leading me to believe her doing high damage is her intended purpose. They also buffed Gestalt Abigail's so that it's between normal Abigail and her shadow counterpart. 

If there's anything I believe you can still make suggestions for, it's to improve her survivability a bit further; I think some skills are simply set in stone at this point. 

Yes - Hopefully with the opportunity for extended play testing over the next month the need for the damage reduction becomes more clear to everyone

[Lee lol]

1 minute ago, Fitzee said:

You're quite persistent about this, aren't you?

Here's a copypaste of a statement I made explaining why this outcome is unlikely:

From the looks of it in my perspective, if Klei felt like it was warranted for Shadow Abigail to be nerfed in the damage department, they would've done so by now, leading me to believe her doing high damage is her intended purpose. They also buffed Gestalt Abigail's so that it's between normal Abigail and her shadow counterpart. 

If there's anything I believe you can still make suggestions for, it's to improve her survivability a bit further; I think some skills are simply set in stone at this point. 

I just don't know what they could do now to improve her survivability, since we have a special attack way as gestalt, hidden mode, hp lock……(though i believe only hp lock has some use) i wish they could remove the 1 second pause after attack. Or, make gestalt move in a bigger range/increase her basic speed……

Make the player tag only applied to gestalt is also a way for balance.

[Steorra]

20 minutes ago, Lee lol said:

Make the player tag only applied to gestalt is also a way for balance.

Don't think so.

There still some players like me who feeling inconvenient to use both shadow or lunar Abi. We prefer regular form of Abi and I think this should be a choice even after skill tree.

Also the player tag is a buff from sisturn, it is not from affinities line, which means it should apply to all form for Abi.

I personally hope we could have another choice for sisturn buff from dark petals. Whether the effect exactly is, it would give more options for different playstyle.

[Lee lol]

1 minute ago, Steorra said:

Don't think so.

There still some players like me who feeling inconvenient to use both shadow or lunar Abi. We prefer regular form of Abi and I think this should be a choice even after skill tree.

Also the player tag is a buff from sisturn, it is not from affinities line, which means it should apply to all form for Abi.

I personally hope we could have another choice for sisturn buff from dark petals. Whether the effect exactly is, it would give more options for different playstyle.

What if lunar flower gives abi player tag while dark petal gives abi the ability to attack shadow monster or sth? 

[Steorra]

8 minutes ago, Lee lol said:

What if lunar flower gives abi player tag while dark petal gives abi the ability to attack shadow monster or sth? 

I'm not sure if dark petal decoration for sisturn would have some effect or not, I do hope our designer would add some effect for it in future.

[Lee lol]

5 minutes ago, Fitzee said:

Only suggestion I have for it is to drastically increase the buff duration for Shadow Abigail; I know you're looking for non-affinity uses, but I just wanted to share.

Good idea. Save the burden of murdering. For non-affinity use, you can just farm dark petals by decorating the grave

[Yifei_]

bump

[Yifei_]

bump. It seems that everyone prefers Shadow Affinity a bit more.

[Echsrick]

me seeing this fun little poll thing thinkin nothing more then just over all vibes


what it actualy is: another discussion about wendy and abigals skill tree, of course what else to expect?

[Yifei_]

3 minutes ago, Echsrick said:

what it actualy is: another discussion about wendy and abigals skill tree, of course what else to expect?

No, this can be discussed elsewhere.