Jump to content

Hydroponic Farms Taking Water Out of a System When Planted with Mealwood


Gnosis
  • Branch: Live Branch Version: Windows Pending

Basically it appears to be the case that if you pipe water into hydroponic farms and plant mealwood on them, even though mealwood does not require any water, what will happen is that after one growth cycle, a 5 kg bottle of water will pop out of the hydroponic farm—effectively taking water out of the system. I'm going to assume this isn't intended, but it may just be a design oversight.


Steps to Reproduce

1. Build a hydroponic farm.

2. Pipe a water supply into the farm tile (hydroponic farm tiles also don't function without a pipe on the tile, so to even be able to use them you either have to pipe actual water to the tile or trick the game by placing a disconnected pipe on the tile).

3. Plant mealwood on the hydroponic farm tile.

4. Wait an entire growth cycle (no clue whether enabling auto-harvest or not makes a difference, in my case I have auto-harvest off).

5. You will probably see a 5k bottle of water pop out of the hydroponic tile, effectively removing water from the pipe when it really shouldn't be doing that?

2023-08-21 21_08_56-Oxygen Not Included.png




User Feedback


Yes, this doesn't happen when you harvest the plants, there is no water bottle output. It also doesn't happen if you select the plant to not be harvested.

Did you do something more than harvesting mealwood on a hydroponic farm while having water underneath it? Because it seems it doesn't happen for me at all. Water stays in pipes just fine.

image.png.08d7677a45fa91ff2248dcc583b9e671.png

Do you have some other specifics in your setup perhaps? Running water in a loop through the tiles doesn't do anything either

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have my plants with auto-harvest disabled and the water that is running through the hydroponic farm tiles is an Aquatuner + Steam Turbine cooling loop. Not sure what could be out of the ordinary but the 5kg bottles of water did indeed appear above my hydroponic farms for some reason.

I haven't exhaustively tested this at all so the only thing I am certain about is that 5kg bottles of water appeared above every one of my hydroponic farm tiles that were planted with mealwood. I also have other hydroponic farms planted with arbor trees in the same save. What I'm not quite sure about is the actual cause of the 5kg bottles of water or when they actually appeared. However, these 5kg bottles of water precisely above hydroponic farm tiles planted with mealwood have appeared more than once.

Also I have reason to believe that this water was actually removed from my cooling loop because the packets of water inside the loop was no longer all the same size.

Edited by Gnosis

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites

I noticed when I was duping seeds, that I had bottles and dirt/ bleach stone/ ect. flying out of the farm tiles. They weren't emptied by dupes, they just got ejected.

I'm guessing that when the detection kicks in (be it maturity/ harvesting/ uprooting/ whatever), then the tile ejects what is "wrong". Since mealwood doesn't require water, it is marked as wrong and out it goes. I don't think it's a bug, more like a logical conclusion to a standardized system.

 

But I'm just guessing. Hope it helps

Edited by AliBob

Share this comment


Link to comment
Share on other sites



Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

×
  • Create New...