It is suggested to add more types of Lures. Specific Lures can better attract some specific fish to bite the hook

[Pig and beefalo]

Here are a few simple ideas. For instance, ice will only and definitely attract Ice Bream, dried or fresh fire nettle only and definitely attract Scorching Sunfish, dried or fresh petals will only and definitely attract Bloomfin Tuna, dried or fresh Dark Petals will only and definitely attract black catfish, and Lucky Gold Nugget will only and definitely attract Dappled Koi or golden koi