Pls replace a designer who have at least 200h DST game experience or at least 100h wendy game experience to redesign wendy's skill tree

[AliceMagtron]

First, im not native english speaker, so I apologize here for next possible unclear part in this text.

I guess this designer have never played wendy nor DST, heres my reason:

1. Pls tell me how many evil flowers naturally spawn in your savedata. Yes, u will never count cause its useless and rare compared to normal flowers. if u really need evil flowers e.g. recover sansity with hivehat, u have to make them by yourself. So, why u design a skill to make a petal from evil petals, which nobody will use it. 

2. Since Abigail can only active 1 potion effect at the same time. Pls tell me who need tripling hp recover for 2 days since u can already auto recover 480hp in 1 day, or which monster u need 2 days 1s shield or 20 dmg counter attack to beat? Thast means this extra duration is mostly wasted, so u have another 3 useless skills.

3. When Wendy join a boss fight, mostly u need to take dmg to let abi alive to get atk bonus, So Why this cloth which let abi take dmg exist? What, u say u can eat food to recover abi's hp? Oh come on, did u ever played wendy? dont u know she has a potion that recover 20hp every second for 30s? also abi cant waer any armor, and take double dmg since shes not a player, which means even a dragonpie cant afford a single atk from boss, and this cloth need an armor slot to effect, so why not just wear an armor and take dmg for abi? Alos it needs 20 evil petals to make, which means u have to die once to make them or use bees. Oh u ask me why only think about boss fight? Of course its because minion monsters never could kill abi, again. its also same for the dark/shadow line, thats redicurious. so, heres another useless skill.

4. OK finally something at least thoughtful idea comes: u can build a tombstone on skull to get a 200hp 15AOE dps reinforcements. u need 1 resurrection materials to build a skull at where u want to. Another good way to waste rubes hmm? Well since its not totally useless which could replace trebuchets for some factory, ill give it a YES. but still, why not trebuchets?

Okey we have a news that thetombstone whend has decorated will spawn evil flowers, but still problems here: just think about how ez u can get a petal, and how ez u can get 4 evil petal + 1 mourning glory, thats definitely worthless. and thats also means if u want to place these tombstones at base to help mates deal hounts. u have to care of burning, and sansity loss.

5. as for 3 new skills for abi, yes they r useless, scare for 1s, dude, whats this for? U have AOE dmg for minions, why let them run around for 1s and abi may cant hit them, just for take 2 less times dmg? same for dash, shes melee or abi get invincible during it so we can play souls like in DST? Good idea then. Loss hate? Why not just ake abi back? Is there anything different?

and others, not a good boost for wendy, same as beefalo line for wigfrid. 

To sum up, i dont think a good designer will design almost half of them useless in a skill tree. He/She is definitly not ready for this project.

As for constructive suggestions, i have some advice here:

1. A skill line to buff potions or let wendy make more kinds of potions, but by buff efficiency rather by increase duration. also in that line u could have a mini bag for potions, just like wig's . Also let different potions can active at the same time.

2. Maybe creat more way to get mourning glory, not only by pipspook.

3. A skill line to buff sisturn, for e.g. it could be filled by other objects to get different buff for wendy and abi. This structure is also a part of wendy game, i dont think designer payed attention on it, they rather let her build other's tombstone or play flowers. Maybe u can play wendy and make a tombstone on yourself's skull, since u have nothing to think of it.

4. some status buff for abi, instead of those useless skills.

5. just let charlie revive my sister and ill join her side, thats all my wish.                                                                                 (just kidding since klei never will.)

[AliceMagtron]

2 hours ago, AliceMagtron said:

4. some status buff for abi, instead of those useless skills.

sorry i mean, more interactive between wendy and abi, like hp link etc.