Day 1 Vibe Check On the new skill trees.

[Evelo]

12 hours ago, WenericMember said:

Wendy on 10%

Wendy being so low is shocking to me. Her skill set is the best so far imo. Almost perfect, just a few tiny adjustments to the armor and swapping the lunar and shadow potions.

[WenericMember]

9 minutes ago, AliceMagtron said:

yes but that cloth occupied armor slot, which means u cant use a lower armor/helmat to take half dmg for better armor/helmat, which means your crown or any other helmat will lose durability faster and u cant active full void or brightshade suit buff, which means u loss both dmg and plane def, for reword, u get some tiny hp regen for abi, thats definitely worthless.

I get the feeling you're a lot more skilled than the average player. A significant amount of people won't be playing with rifts.  And you're right about increased durability loss, but in exchange you get  about 4x max Hp + Regen. For most people its at lest pretty good, though yes it should be reworked into a more synergistic skill..

8 minutes ago, Evelo said:

Wendy being so low is shocking to me. Her skill set is the best so far imo. Almost perfect, just a few tiny adjustments to the armor and swapping the lunar and shadow potions.

I think you're in the minority of people in terms of how powerful you want skill trees to be, which fair enough, you're entitled to an opinion, but I wouldn't find it particularly surprising after how discussions on skill trees have played out in the past year+. Like even accepting that hers should be weaker than other survivors, I find its still shockingly weak in comparison to pretty much everyone else's. Not only does it only give extremely situational and limited tools to deal with her substantial weaknesses. Those skills can be obtained with like... 5 insight.

[AliceMagtron]

18 minutes ago, WenericMember said:

I've talked about why I think the grave skills & dark petals lives have potential with singificant buffs. I'd also say the sisturn skills, while mostly filler, are alright (again the tier 3 skill needs buffs though). FInally the command skills are fine. Dodge is quicker than unsummoning, the attack at skill is convenient in a pinch. Panics kinda meh though.

i do think sisturn should have more potential than evil petal, if they design a skill line which allow u to fill more kinds of stuffs to get different buffs, that should be much better than that cloth, that cloth dont increase any limit of wendy nor make early game easier. the fact is designer payed too less attention on sisturn, Jason rather to make a mourning wendy like a crazy necromancer with graves and evil petal.

[Tim34123415]

just re work Wendy skill tree please

[WenericMember]

1 minute ago, AliceMagtron said:

i do think sisturn should have more potential than evil petal, if they design a skill line which allow u to fill more kinds of stuffs to get different buffs, that should be much better than that cloth, that cloth dont increase any limit of wendy nor make early game easier. the fact is designer payed too less attention on sisturn, Jason rather to make a mourning wendy like a crazy necromancer with graves and evil petal.

Yeah, the fact that the sisturn and potions were mostly pushed off to the side is bizarre, especially with how low Wendy's skill count it.

Like the Petals skills would be good as an addition to a strong skill tree, kind of like Wigfrid's beefalo skills, for those who want to try something different, but Wendy's tree doesn't have a strong basis.

[AliceMagtron]

28 minutes ago, WenericMember said:

Like the Petals skills would be good as an addition to a strong skill tree, kind of like Wigfrid's beefalo skills, for those who want to try something different, but Wendy's tree doesn't have a strong basis.

Right, the problem is wigs beefalo skills only very few ppl will pick it, and more than half of them just go make a saddle and change the character. and now, the additional unpopular worthless skill line becomes wendys main skill line, thats the most funny thing ever klei did. and these petal skills have none of the business about all wendys borned skill, thats really redicurious and shame.

[WenericMember]

1 minute ago, AliceMagtron said:

Right, the problem is wigs beefalo skills only very few ppl will pick it, and more than half of them just go make a saddle and change the character. and now, the additional unpopular worthless skill line becomes wendys main skill line, thats the most funny thing ever klei did. and these petal skills have none of the business about all wendys borned skill, thats really redicurious and shame.

Yeah, personally I like the beef skills and use them in my main build, but they should NOT be the centrepiece.

[Echsrick]

i realy dislike wortox napsack and came up with an idea (i copy paste text) in how it would be better

i think to fix it sould first of all NOT BE USED AS A WEAPON but more so a tool, like a special bug net that can make you able to catch more things then bees and butterflys, maybe a 2 stage, first where it can only take small creatures and objects like bees, spiders, PLANTED FLOWERS that dont become petals and are able to be placed anywhere if you so desire, tree stumbs, planted carrots and other farm plants, and stage 2 napsack can take more medium size things like pigs, baby beefalos, grass, twiggs and berry plants, gravestones, oversized crops and suspicous marble, and the napsack has its own inventory that can only be filled with those special items i mention and some more if you think it would fit of kind things, i think that would be way more funny and would be so much more fitting for "wortox was with krampus alot so he starts doin his own stealing things bag" then it being a weapon PLEASE klei, of all the things the napsack the most importand part of it

[WenericMember]

2 hours ago, Tim34123415 said:

just re work Wendy skill tree please

4th Wendy Rework letsgooooooooooooo

Character Refresh, updated refresh, skill tree and skill treee rework.

[AliceMagtron]

On 11/23/2024 at 2:52 AM, WenericMember said:

4th Wendy Rework letsgooooooooooooo

considering the number of vote, that should be around 40~50