Wigfrid is an Example of a "good" skill tree

[Kevinnator]

On 2/2/2024 at 9:35 PM, Jakepeng99 said:

▪Commanders helm planar defence skill: It is obselete. Use a brightshade helm for much better results. It could be buffed to make the commander helm much more viable in riffs, or be replaced with something else.

8 planar defence is only a small amount less than the brightshade helmet, combine it with the +5 planar defence you can give her, she can technically be more protected from planar than somsone with a brightshade helmet. The brightshade helmet IS still better due to being repairable but the commander's helm is fairly cheap and can be made before rifts for the entire team, allowing everyone to have some planar protection without grinding Nightmare Werepig.
I get what you say but I just see it as an option to basically be fully prepared for rifts without needing rift armour. The small amount of insulation it provides can also make it a useful armour for fighting rift enemies and bosses during winter.

On 2/2/2024 at 9:35 PM, Jakepeng99 said:

-Saddle is weak. The "tank" saddle niche should not be Wigfrid exclusive either. Instead it could offer unique abilities to the beefalo like life steal.

I kinda wished the +10 planar damage wasn't removed from the beta. It'd allow the Beefalo to have its own version of Wigfrid's +25% more damage. The Beef still wouldn't deal more damage than Wigfrid but it's still an infinite use weapon. It also allowed the Battle Saddle to be like 1 damage less than a War Saddle with a normal character which would make it a bit worth it.

[arubaro]

2 hours ago, Kevinnator said:

8 planar defence is only a small amount less than the brightshade helmet, combine it with the +5 planar defence you can give her, she can technically be more protected from planar than somsone with a brightshade helmet. The brightshade helmet IS still better due to being repairable but the commander's helm is fairly cheap and can be made before rifts for the entire team, allowing everyone to have some planar protection without grinding Nightmare Werepig.
I get what you say but I just see it as an option to basically be fully prepared for rifts without needing rift armour. The small amount of insulation it provides can also make it a useful armour for fighting rift enemies and bosses during winter.

Dont forget the knockback protection

 

Edit. About the topic: i think wigfrid's skill tree has good perks but the whole skill tree is horrible, you dont have much paths and there are bad perks or perks for 1 use like the song container. Most skill trees have very few configurations but wigfrid's and Wolfgang's are the worst ones in this regard