Perhaps you could make the butter cost 5 butterfly wings, because 5 petals = 5 health, but a stick of butter gives 40 health, and since 5 wings give 40 health and butter comes from butterflies, the recipe will make more sense like this.
You called the big portrait "squidward" again. Same applies to saveslot portraits and selectscreen, I fixed it and I can send it to you. Btw, add him neutral spiders. It looks weird that spiders attack a spider. Also the character model has a bit problems.