I've tried countless times to select a profile icon, but it never loads properly when joining lobbies.
(Another thing I've noticed is that if you select an icon with the weavable filter turned on, then turning it off and selecting a Loyal icon, sometimes, both icons will have a checkmark on them.)
Steps to Reproduce
I haven't seen this happen to anyone else yet. I didn't do anything specific that might've cause this, except for perhaps unravelling icon duplicates.
This issue has not been confirmed by a developer yet.