Straw Roll vs Fur Roll vs Tent

[Rosten]

So, after mulling it over a bit, i couldn't really decide which of the three was the best, so i've come to you guys for some opinions ^_^

so, im going to list the pros and cons of each item (both from the wiki and my own observations) and let you guys decide which is the best - Note - Putting em all in spoilers because its a fairly big list

 

Straw Roll -

Pros

1 - Restores 33 Sanity

2 - Skips night

3 - Portable

4 - Doesn't require very hard to get resources

Cons

1 - Lose 75 Hunger

2 - 1 use

 

Fur Roll -

Pros

1 - Restores 33 Sanity

2 - Restores 30 Health

3 - 3 uses 

4 - Sets temperature to max

5 - Portable

Cons

1 - Much more difficult to get then a straw roll or a tent, due to the caves being a very dangerous place

2 - Lose 75 Hunger

 

Tent - 

Pros

1 - Restores 60 Health

2 - Restores 50 Sanity

3 - 6 uses

Cons

1 - Stationary

2 - Lose 75 Hunger

3 - A little harder to get then the straw roll, for spiders can be dangerous to new players

 

So, what do you think? which of the three are superior?

[Yay]

Sleep is for the weak!!!!

[Rosten]

Sleep is for the weak!!!!

Reason i sleep alot is because, for 1 im using the Badass wilson mod, which at night drains your sanity really fast, and my frequent outings generally leave me with very low health so i have to sleep alot until i can get some more healing salves

[Yay]

Reason i sleep alot is because, for 1 im using the Badass wilson mod, which at night drains your sanity really fast, and my frequent outings generally leave me with very low health so i have to sleep alot until i can get some more healing salves

Fair argument, but only download character mods and I never found the use to sleep yet And I tend to need food a lot (I still a noob) so sleeping would only be a burden for me

[Rosten]

Fair argument, but only download character mods and I never found the use to sleep yet And I tend to need food a lot (I still a noob) so sleeping would only be a burden for me

If you want my opinion, the absolute best use for sleep, is carrying around a fur roll and some meaty stew/dragonpies for long adventures so you don't have to keep using resources to make fires and such

[Deacon_Blue]

I almost never sleep, exception only being when I intentionally drive myself insane.

[KidneyBeanBoy]

It depends on the situation. If you're adventuring, straw roll is best to avoid grue, and preserve resources, but the tent is best if you are turtling.

[ailailou]

I'd say a fur roll in a tent would be best.

[Cynical Cynicist]

Once you get enough Bunnymen it's easy to harvest bunny puffs, so it's worth investing them in creating fur rolls (especially during winter).

[Nebulous]

Straw roll. Cheap, easy, I can carry it around, and I can make it on the fly. I almost never sleep in my bases, it's usually when I'm running around doing thing I shouldn't.

[Luggs]

I really only make the tent for my base to look nice. Though whenever I summon Abigail, I make a strawroll to get my sanity back.

[Rosten]

Me personally, i usually carry around a good 1-2 stacks of grass with me for things like torches, straw rolls and stuff, but the tent is my favorite because of its ease to get, and it restores health, the fur roll is pretty difficult to get mid-game considering, your probably still living off meat by then and bunnymen are a pain to fight in groups

[gummie]

vs Tam O' Shanter

[KidneyBeanBoy]

vs Living in the guts of a winter koalefant.

[Cynical Cynicist]

You should be able to take shelter inside the carcass of a large mammal (Deerclops, Beefalo, Koalefant) during particularly harsh winter storms.

[TeoSS69]

There's not one "best" option. Well maybe yes, since the fur roll is essentialy a better version of the straw roll, but comparing it to the tent? Nope. It's like comparing a laptop to a desktop computer.


i could swear i posted this message yesterday...

[Cynical Cynicist]

Fur roll for travel, tent for bases.

[the truthseeker]

When in my base in winter above ground a tent is superior for restoring sanity. When exploring nomadicly a straw roll is fine. However it's just not cost effective to get the puffs to make fur rolls (especially with the bug that doesn't reset warmth.)

[Hopperruss]

I've never slept a day.

[Cynical Cynicist]

When in my base in winter above ground a tent is superior for restoring sanity. When exploring nomadicly a straw roll is fine. However it's just not cost effective to get the puffs to make fur rolls (especially with the bug that doesn't reset warmth.)

 

Fur rolls do restore warmth; it's straw rolls and tents that don't. Besides, if you get a lot of rabbit hutches above ground it's easy to harvest bunny buffs.

[the truthseeker]

Fur rolls do restore warmth; it's straw rolls and tents that don't. Besides, if you get a lot of rabbit hutches above ground it's easy to harvest bunny buffs.

There's a bug in the code that prevents it currently. 

[aznXD]

speaking of tents, is it possible that any of you guys could do a mod on the old tent verions where you could switch charaters?

[Ortorin]

Wait, you can sleep in this game?

[the truthseeker]

Wait, you can sleep in this game?

 

Unless you're Wickerbottom, yes. 

[Ortorin]

Unless you're Wickerbottom, yes. 

 

Remember that topic I made about wishing I never read the wiki? xD

 

I never see a point to sleeping... I got things to do in the night, like catching fireflies or wiping out hordes of spiders. (it's so much faster to clear the forest when they ALL run at you at the same time xD and I let teh dens stay there so I have something to do the next night.)